Wednesday 25 May 2011

UPDATED: UMNO Mamaks Are NOT Real Malays and Should Speak on Behalf of KIMMA instead

UPDATE..27 May 2011

Quote:

"
Indians DON'T require representation by the MIC really.They can do so through Nor Mohamad Yakob, Naina Merican, Azeez Rahim, Zambry Kadir et al."
-"Sakmongkol AK47


A Reader's Comment

"...I always find it strange why UMNO MEMBERS are getting darker all the time.

Not only that these DARKER people seem to be more vocal, in fact much more than the ORIGINAL Malays. ...."

-Anonymous
Read here the verbal diarrhoea from the pretentiously religious Blogger "Mahaguru58" aka Zainol Abideen in his response to Sakmongkol AK47's article

- End of Update -

Quote

"... I find myself in strange territory listening to people like Reezal Merican, or Rahim Azeez speak for the Malays.

I would have thought, Malays are better off if THESE people speak on behalf of KIMMA.

(Note: KIMMA = Kongres India Muslim Malaysia, OR Malaysian Indian Muslim Congress =MIMC)

How can we force ourselves to suffer fools by allowing ourselves to consume the hate spewing writings of
some bloggers whose Malay-ness are questionable?

Why isn't the peddler of rancid-curry speaking on behalf and FOR KIMMA members?

Jadi jadi lah kita orang Melayu kena tipu.

I think Malays have got enough talented people to speak for ourselves.

Then we have those who pretend they speak for UMNO but are themselves NOT UMNO members.

The REAL UMNO man WOULDN'T speak of an imagined clash of Christians and Muslims or spun the story about Christians taking over this country.

Does a Malay cease to be a Malay if he is not UMNO member?

Being UMNO is NOT an absolute requirement to fight for a Malay cause.


(And) those Malays in power have not helped other Malays.

So if UMNO insists that UMNO is Malay and Malay is UMNO, then by extension, Malays in power do not help the rest of Malays will also mean, UMNO in power does not help the rest of the Malays.

UMNO people must be realistic on this. One doesn't stop becoming Malay if one dismisses UMNO. People are already doing that if you still don't realize it.

Yet the leadership is hyping themselves, aided by a pliant audio visual and print media into believing all is well. Ignorance is really bliss.

-"Sakmongkol AK47"

Talking Malay on False Premises

by

"Sakmongkol AK47"

Let us demolish one pet belief of UMNO people and those who think they speak for UMNO.

It's time for the REAL Malay to speak for the Malay.

Where have the real Malays gone?


How can we force ourselves to suffer fools by allowing ourselves to consume the hate spewing writings of some bloggers whose Malay-ness are questionable?

Photobucket
( CHINESE Muslim Convert Wannabe Malay)

Photobucket Photobucket


Blogger "Mahaguru58"

Why isn't the peddler of rancid curry speaking on behalf and for Kimma members? He looks more kitol-ish that the person he castigates as Kitol. Why isn't the gold nugget seller doing the same? We thank you but no thanks.

Jadi jadi lah KITA orang MELAYU kena tipu.

I find myself in strange territory listening to people like Reezal Merican, or Rahim Azeez speak for the Malays. I would have thought, Malays are better off if these people speak on behalf of KIMMA.

I think Malays have got enough talented people to speak for ourselves.

Then we have those who pretend they speak for UMNO but are themselves not UMNO members. Can they have the same thinking dynamics of an UMNO member? And I am not even differentiating between good and bad thinking- just undifferentiated UMNO thinking. Why is this important? It's important because then, what we say can be leavened with realistic assessment. Then we can appreciate the UMNO spirit.
Without the UMNO spirit, what you write is mechanical.

The real UMNO man wouldn't speak of an imagined clash of Christians and Muslims or spun the story about Christians taking over this country. I think Malays are already suffering from an overdose of ghost stories and will NOT want to add to their consumption ,manufactured tales about DAP becoming PM or Christians taking over this country.

Does a Malay cease to be a Malay if he is not UMNO member? Being UMNO is not an absolute requirement to fight for a Malay cause. Even being Malay is not an absolute guarantee that Malay interests are taken care of.

Both require the right Malay with the right values and the UMNO Malay with the right values.

Consider the record before us. From the day we got independence, most of our MBs are Malays. The top bosses in the Police and the army are Malays. The KSUs and TKSUs are almost invariably Malays. The top government officers are Malays. All the District officers are. All penghulus are Malays. All the Kings? All are Malays.

Now, one would be justified into assuming that given the fact that almost all the important orifice bearers are Malays and the governmental institutions we have are peopled by Malays, the lot of the Malays would be greatly improved or would have been vastly improved. Wouldn't it?

Well, in terms of control of the economy, Malay economic interest is just about 20%. That's 20% of the overall wealth being shared by 65% of the population.
  • We would further imagine that Malays would own more land in this country.
  • We would also imagine that Malays owned better housing.
  • Their education would be of higher standard.
With Malays in power, there would have been more rich Malays than rich non Malays. Yet in the top 20 richest in Malaysia, you would find probably one fellow.

In the top 40, you start getting more Malays but you also get more non Malays.

So what conclusion can you deduce from these observations?

The only valid and justifiable conclusion, is having Malays up there does not readily translate into Malay prominence in any of the fields we mentioned.

It follows from here, that positioning Malays in strategic offices is not necessarily beneficial and advantageous to Malays.

The other conclusion is those Malays in power have not helped other Malays. So if UMNO insists that UMNO is Malay and Malay in UMNO, then by extension, Malays in power do not help the rest of Malays will also mean, UMNO in power does not help the rest of the Malays.

UMNO people must be realistic on this. One doesn't stop becoming Malay if one dismisses UMNO. People are already doing that if you still don't realize it. 1.5 million UMNO protested by not voting in UMNO candidates.

That should be interpreted as a rejection of not merely the candidates but perhaps more so of the policies and vision that UMNO projects.

1.5 million Members didn't share in the vision of UMNO. 3.7 million Malay voters didn't subscribe to the UMNO ideals pedaled by UMNO leaders.

Yet the leadership is hyping themselves, aided by a pliant audio visual and print media into believing all is well. Ignorance is really bliss.

7 comments:

yapchongyee said...

For the life of me, I just cannot connect to the idea that if one is Chinese or Malay or Indian, one would prefer other Malay, Chinese or Indian to be as successful as myself. Why is it something preferable to have all Malays rich powerful and rich, and to have all Chinese or Indians poor ? Is this what makes men happy; to have all men of the same race rich & powerful ? I can't understand why this is so because one can only be rich if one is 1 in a million(1 man with a million and all the others do not have that million). If all 23 million Malays have a million or more then, which Malay is a millionaire ?

Conversely, if all 5 million Chinese were poor and out living in the streets, is that preferable to having 5 million Chinese who are able to fend for themselves ? Will it make the Malays happy if all these 5 million Chinese became poor ? Therefore let me ask the Malays, what is it that is so desirable to want something that is so ridiculous and unachievable ?

Malaysia cannot achieve this nonsense because if Malaysia had 23 million Malay millionaires, then what is the Ringgit going to be
worth ? The other impossibility is the question, WHAT RESOURCES ARE MALAYSIA endowed with to be able to generate so much wealth ? Tin has run out Palm oil is insufficient to generate so much export to make 23 million Malays millionaires. What resources has Malaysia got that will do what the Malays want ?

If there are 23 Malay millionaires, then is there enough land in all of Malaysia to accommodate the huge mansions that Malays want for show ? What UMNO wants and what the Malays want is so unachievable and utter nonsense that it goes against common sense. Samangot 47 has stated openly that the Malays have already got everything and all that the government can give to the Malays and nothing to give to the Chinese; has it improved the happiness of the Malays ? NO ! because in the affairs of man, it is just so much nonsense that all men are equal ! THERE ARE ALWAYS MEN WHO ARE BETTER ENDOWED BY GOD OR BORN TO BE BETTER THAN OTHERS, that is the law of nature. Good men become leaders, and the lesser men become followers. UMNO & the Malays cannot alter what nature has ordered for man. Not all horses are born to be through-bred,and not all race horses are winners, because if that is possible then there cannot be "the sport of horse racing !"

Anonymous said...

well said bro,me too are getting nauseated listening to this "melayu jawi" championing so called malay's right, they should look themselves in the mirror. a lot of them are joining UMNO & become leaders of the real malay, as usual we're a mere followers with follower's benefit. it's about time we kick them out..

Anonymous said...

Your PM was a "mamak", why the hell did the Malays vote him into power! Bodoh!

Anonymous said...

apa masalahnye ni bro? Melayu itu islam, dan islam tidak smestinya melayu! bukankah lagi elok jika lebih ramai umat islam yg bersama-sama mempertahankan melayu di atas nama islam? ko ni pembangkang dalam selimut ke?

Anonymous said...

Gee, I always find it strange why UMNO members are getting darker all the time. Not only that these darker people seem to be more vocal in fact much more than the original Malays. It's a phenomenon only found in Malaya.

Anonymous said...

Hairan...

Baru Nak Tahu Ke?

Most of us who choose to ignore UMNO do so because we wish to ignore the Mamaks that Rule UMNO!!

Khun Pana aka johanssm said...

It is not about the Mamaks or having the fake Malays in umno.
It is about umno's hypocrisy
If Indian muslim such as those Azeez , Reezal or Mydeen can be umno members so why can't that Tee Rid Huan cannot join umno?
Abdullah badawi's 2nd. wife jeanne is NOT even a malay but she is an umno member.
A Non Malay can become a bumiputar overnight.
But that Tee Rid Huan can speak and defend ketuanan until he drops dead but he won't get to be a bumiputar.
It is true that Islam is not about Malays and it is true that the Malays is not about Islam.
As there are many Malays that are not Muslims and there are more Muslims whom are not Malay.
The main issues are that the umno playing and messing the minds of Malays and confusing Islam as their religion.